Division — House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Bill: Division 19 - 15 Oct 2024 (Rejected)

Voting Chart

◯ Aye ()

▢ No ()

△ Abstain (↗︎)

Hover or click on a point to see information

 

 

 

Legislation Summary

A rejection of proposed changes to the House of Lords due to concerns over effectiveness and lack of consensus.

Legislation Key Points

This House declines to give a Second Reading to the House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Bill for several reasons:

  • It is viewed as an ineffective method for enacting significant constitutional changes.
  • The proposed alterations to the House of Lords' composition necessitate broader considerations related to prior government commitments.
  • The phased approach of the bill may impede thorough examination of profound changes to the dynamic between the two Houses.
  • There are concerns about potential unintended outcomes and a general lack of political agreement on reforms.
  • The bill does not include provisions for comprehensive consultation and pre-legislative scrutiny.
Raw Legislation Text

“this House declines to give a Second Reading to the House of Lords (Hereditary Peers) Bill because it is not an acceptable or effective method of enacting major constitutional change, because it proposes a significant alteration to the composition of the House of Lords which should not be considered in isolation from other changes, having regard to the undertakings given by the then Government in 1999, because it drip-feeds changes that hinder proper scrutiny of measures that could change the relationship between the two Houses, because it risks unintended consequences, does not reflect the lack of political consensus on House of Lords reform and does not provide for full consultation and pre-legislative scrutiny which would give the opportunity to consider the case for overall reform, seek cross-party engagement on proposals, and review the implications of all proposals.”-(Sir Oliver Dowden.)

Suffrago gets even better with a larger screen!

Unfortunately your screen and/or window size is too small to view all this page can do! If you view this page on a larger device or in a larger window you can see how each MP voted, and go directly to their constituency to see how their constituents reacted to this vote.